Skip to content
Segni di Fede
Articolo

Lourdes and healing: how case control works

In Lourdes there is a distinct medical and ecclesial process: we see how the dossiers are collected and why the recognition of healing is rare.

The healings of Lourdes It is important to distinguish three levels: a healing referred to by the pilgrim, a medically inexplicated healing and a possible ecclesiastical recognition as a miracle.

How a signal arises

A person who believes that he is healed can present his medical documentation to the Bureau des Constatations Médicales in Lourdes.

What does “unexplained” mean?

It does not mean automatically “miraculous.” It means that, on the basis of the available medical knowledge and the collected documentation, there was no sufficient explanation for the observed change.

What criteria are considered

Traditionally, special attention is paid to the certainty of the previous diagnosis, to the severity of the disease, to the absence of a therapy capable of explaining the result, to the rapidity of healing and its stability over time.

Who decides if it is a miracle

The medical and ecclesiastical judgement are distinct. Doctors can assess whether a healing remains without convincing medical explanation; the competent ecclesiastical authority assesses the religious meaning of the case.

Because the official numbers are much lower than the testimonies

Thousands of people tell about improvements, consolations or healings during a pilgrimage, but only a small part of the cases have sufficient documentation to enter a formal process.

Faith and prudence

To tell Lourdes precisely means to avoid both sensationalism and reductionism. For believers healing can have a spiritual meaning; from a medical point of view every case requires independent documentation and evaluation.

Sources and further reading